Pak Imtehan
History
Why the Treaty of Versailles Led to World War Two
In June 1919, the French commander Ferdinand Foch read the terms of the peace settlement that had just ended the First World War. His verdict was blunt: “This is not peace. It is an armistice for twenty years.”
He turned out to be almost exactly right. Germany signed the Treaty of Versailles on 28 June 1919. Germany invaded Poland on 1 September 1939, just over twenty years later, and Europe was at war again. The treaty did not cause the Second World War by itself, but it left behind anger, instability and unfinished business, and Adolf Hitler would use all three.
A War Without a Visible Defeat
The First World War ended in an unusual way. When Germany asked for an armistice in November 1918, no foreign army stood on German soil. Its soldiers still held ground in France and Belgium, and German newspapers had been predicting victory until the final months.
So when defeat came, many Germans could not believe it was real. They had not watched their cities fall or their country occupied. This made it easy for nationalists to claim that the army had been “stabbed in the back” by politicians at home. Germans who believed they had not truly lost a war were not ready to accept a peace written for a beaten nation.
Three Men, Three Different Goals
The peace was shaped at the Paris Peace Conference in 1919, mainly by the leaders of three countries, often called the Big Three. Each wanted something different.
Georges Clemenceau of France wanted security above all. Northern France had been devastated, and Germany had invaded France twice within his lifetime. He wanted Germany weakened so it could never attack again.
Woodrow Wilson of the United States wanted a fairer peace based on his Fourteen Points, including self-determination for nations and a League of Nations to settle future disputes.
David Lloyd George of Britain stood between them. The British public wanted Germany punished, yet he worried that a humiliated Germany might turn to revolution or revenge.
The final treaty was a compromise among these goals. Many historians see it as too harsh for Germany to accept, but not harsh enough to stop Germany from rising again.
A Peace Germany Was Not Allowed to Negotiate
Germany was not invited to the negotiating table. Its delegation received the finished terms on 7 May 1919 and was given only limited time to send written objections. Few changes were made.
The reaction in Germany was fury. Chancellor Philipp Scheidemann resigned rather than sign. In a famous speech, he asked what hand would not wither that bound itself and Germany in such chains. On 21 June 1919, German sailors scuttled their own interned fleet at Scapa Flow in Scotland rather than hand the ships over.
In the end, Germany had no real choice. Refusal risked an Allied invasion. Two ministers of the new Weimar Republic, Hermann Müller and Johannes Bell, signed the treaty in the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles, the same hall where the German Empire had been proclaimed in 1871. The date was also the fifth anniversary of the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, the event that had started the war.
Germans called the treaty the “Diktat”, a dictated peace. The word reflected an anger that shaped German politics for the next twenty years.
What Germany Lost
The terms touched almost every part of German life.
Territory and people
Germany lost about 65,000 square kilometres of land and around 7 million people.
Alsace-Lorraine returned to France.
West Prussia and Posen went to the new Polish state, creating the Polish Corridor, a strip of land that cut East Prussia off from the rest of Germany.
The port of Danzig, with a mostly German population, became a Free City under the League of Nations.
The coal-rich Saar was placed under League control for 15 years, with its coal going to France.
All German colonies overseas were taken away.
Military limits
The army was capped at 100,000 men, and conscription was banned.
No tanks, no military aircraft, no submarines and no air force were allowed.
The navy was limited to six old battleships and 15,000 men.
The Rhineland, the region bordering France, was demilitarised and occupied by Allied troops for up to 15 years.
Guilt and payment
Article 231, later called the “War Guilt Clause”, stated that Germany and its allies were responsible for the losses caused by their aggression.
This became the legal basis for reparations, payments for war damage. In May 1921, the total was fixed at 132 billion gold marks.
Article 80 forbade Germany from uniting with Austria without the League’s approval.
War Guilt and Reparations
Of all these terms, the war guilt clause and reparations caused the deepest bitterness. Many Germans read Article 231 as a moral judgment that blamed their nation alone for the war. Every German government, democratic or not, rejected it.
The British economist John Maynard Keynes, who had attended the conference, resigned in protest and wrote The Economic Consequences of the Peace in 1919. He called the settlement a “Carthaginian peace”, comparing it to Rome’s destruction of Carthage, and warned that crushing Germany’s economy would damage all of Europe. His book was widely read and convinced many in Britain and the United States that the treaty was unjust. This sense of guilt would later shape how Britain responded to Hitler.
The Weimar Republic Pays the Price
The young German democracy carried the burden of a treaty it had been forced to sign. Nationalists called the politicians who accepted it the “November criminals”, and some of them paid with their lives. Matthias Erzberger, who had signed the armistice, was assassinated in 1921. Foreign Minister Walther Rathenau, who had tried to work within the treaty, was murdered in 1922.
Reparations soon led to open crisis. In January 1923, after Germany fell behind on coal deliveries, French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr, Germany’s industrial heartland. The German government backed a campaign of passive resistance and printed money to pay striking workers. The result was the hyperinflation of 1923, which wiped out the savings of millions.
Recovery came only when reparations were reorganised. The Dawes Plan of 1924 reduced annual payments and brought in American loans. Under Foreign Minister Gustav Stresemann, Germany signed the Locarno Treaties in 1925 and joined the League of Nations in 1926. The Young Plan of 1929 lowered the total further, to a theoretical 112 billion gold marks.
For a few years, it seemed the treaty could be revised peacefully. But the system rested on American money. Germany was paying reparations largely with American loans, and when the Wall Street Crash struck in 1929, those loans disappeared. The Great Depression hit Germany harder than almost anywhere else, and the treaty became an easy target for every extremist who wanted someone to blame.
Hitler’s Most Powerful Weapon
From his earliest speeches in Munich, Hitler attacked Versailles. He promised to tear up the “Diktat”, rebuild the army, recover lost lands and restore German honour. For millions of voters suffering through the Depression, the treaty explained everything that had gone wrong since 1918.
Once in power from 1933, Hitler dismantled the treaty step by step. Each move was a gamble, and each time Britain and France did little to stop him.
January 1935: In a League-supervised vote, about 90 percent of Saar voters chose to rejoin Germany. Hitler presented it as a victory over Versailles.
March 1935: Germany announced it would no longer obey the treaty’s disarmament terms, revealed the existence of an air force and introduced conscription.
June 1935: Britain signed the Anglo-German Naval Agreement, accepting a German navy larger than the treaty allowed. Britain itself had now set aside part of the settlement.
7 March 1936: German troops marched into the demilitarised Rhineland. French forces were far stronger, and German generals were nervous about a French response. France chose not to act, and Britain advised against action.
March 1938: Germany annexed Austria in the Anschluss, directly breaking Article 80.
September 1938: At the Munich Conference, Britain’s Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain and France agreed to let Germany take the Sudetenland from Czechoslovakia, home to a large German-speaking population.
Versailles itself partly explains why Britain and France allowed this. Many British leaders and voters, influenced by arguments like those of Keynes, believed Germany had been treated unfairly. Hitler’s early demands, such as German troops on German soil or Germans joining Germany, seemed to correct old injustices rather than threaten Europe. Appeasement was, in part, an attempt to fix the peace of 1919.
The Corridor and the Final Crisis
After Munich, Hitler turned to the last major grievance left by the treaty: Danzig and the Polish Corridor. He demanded the return of Danzig and a route across the Corridor to East Prussia. This time, Britain and France had seen enough. In March 1939, Germany occupied the rest of Czechoslovakia, which had nothing to do with German grievances. Britain then guaranteed Poland’s independence.
On 1 September 1939, Germany invaded Poland. Two days later, Britain and France declared war. The territorial settlement drawn in Paris twenty years earlier had become the trigger for a new world war.
Was the Treaty Really to Blame?
The link between Versailles and the Second World War is real, but historians warn against treating it as the whole story.
The treaty was not as crushing as Germans believed. Germany remained united, kept most of its industry, and was still the largest nation in central Europe. Compared with the treaty Germany itself imposed on Russia at Brest-Litovsk in March 1918, which took away vast territory, Versailles was milder.
Reparations were less than they seemed. Much of the 132 billion figure existed only on paper. Germany actually paid around 20 billion gold marks by 1932, according to the Reparation Commission, and payments ended that year.
Keynes had critics. In 1946, the French economist Étienne Mantoux argued in The Carthaginian Peace that Keynes had exaggerated the treaty’s economic harm.
The peace was never enforced. The United States Senate never ratified the treaty, and the United States never joined the League of Nations. Britain and France disagreed over how strictly to apply the terms. A treaty that is resented but not enforced is perhaps the most dangerous kind.
Other forces mattered as much. The Great Depression, the weakness of the League, the policy of appeasement, and above all Hitler’s own ideology of conquest and racial war drove Europe toward catastrophe. Hitler’s ambitions went far beyond reversing Versailles, as his later invasion of the Soviet Union showed.
Versailles did not make war inevitable. It created grievances, and the failures of the 1930s allowed a determined leader to exploit them.
The Twenty-Year Armistice
The Treaty of Versailles tried to do two things at once: punish Germany and build a lasting peace. It managed neither. It humiliated Germany enough to create lasting anger, but left it strong enough to seek revenge. It promised a new world order, yet the country that had proposed it walked away.
When the victors met again after 1945, they remembered these mistakes. Germany was occupied and rebuilt rather than simply punished, and the United States stayed engaged in Europe through the Marshall Plan and NATO. The peace that followed the Second World War was designed by people who had watched the first one fail.
Foch had judged the settlement correctly in 1919. It solved too little and angered too many, and twenty years later, Europe paid the price.
Read Next: https://pakimtehan.com/blog/history-explained/how-hitler-came-to-power-in-1933
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!